Cantigas d'Escarnho e de Maldizer dos Cancioneiros Medievais ... by Manuel Rodrigues Lapa

It's just that you are being more destructive than contributive right now. Philologue37 ( talk) 20:28, 6 September 2022 (UTC) Reply I don't dislike your contributions you seem to know the subject, and can be a great help. Still, incomparably better than the incompetent and shameless NOVA site. There is also the new Galician edition of the whole corpus, done by an endogamic group convinced of their omniscience, and not very honest about the sources of their text. It is, in my view, deeply dishonest and hopelessly flawed.

Why bother doing anything there, when there are so many big fish in miniscule ponds to contend with? The NOVA edition is largely taken from other editions, without attribution. You ask why I don't complain on the Portuguese and Galician pages. It is simply not worth the trouble to rewrite these articles, especially when that means playing see-saw (with those who undo what I put there and replace it with whatever is available online). AnAkemie ( talk) 18:10, 6 September 2022 (UTC) Reply You need not take it personally. What if you actually contribute if you think you can do better than years of user contributions? Also, the article is tagged as Wikipedia:Stub so you can expand it however you want. Maybe you could complain on any one of those two Wikipedias, since people there would be way more invested in helping, and I suppose you speak one of these languages. Not even the page on the Galician Wikipedia is that expanded. I just translated the page from the page on the Portuguese Wikipedia. You seem really invested in complaining in the English Wikipedia about Portuguese-Galician stuff. Philologue37 ( talk) 13:42, 6 September 2022 (UTC) Reply The NOVA site is not a reliable source for the text of the poems and their descriptions of the genres are the scholarly equivalent of garbage. This article is junk - no credit rating could be low enough to describe it.

Cantigas d'Escarnho e de Maldizer dos Cancioneiros Medievais ... by Manuel Rodrigues Lapa